The Cheapest Quote Can Cost You More
That bargain policy looks great on paper. Until you actually need to use it.
Ryan Parrack
Everybody likes saving money. We get it — we shop our own policies too. But when it comes to insurance, the cheapest quote is often cheaper because it leaves something out.
Here's what we mean:
A couple in Randolph County came to us after a single-vehicle accident. Hit a patch of ice on Route 33, slid into a guardrail. Nobody hurt, but the front end was done. They had the cheapest auto policy they could find. No rental car coverage. Their car sat in the shop for two weeks while they figured out rides to work. That "savings" of $30 a month? Gone in three days of borrowing rides and missing shifts.
We've seen it with homeowners too. Someone saves a few hundred a year by going with the bare-bones policy, then their furnace shorts out mid-January. The whole system needs replaced — $11,000. They didn't have equipment breakdown coverage, so their homeowners policy wouldn't touch it. Equipment breakdown coverage, which often costs a couple extra dollars a month, is designed for that kind of loss.
What Makes a Quote Cheap
It's not magic. There are only a few ways to lower a premium:
- Raise the deductible
- Lower the coverage limits
- Remove optional coverages
- Go with a company that offers less service
None of those are free. You're just paying later instead of now.
What to Actually Compare
When you're looking at quotes, don't just compare the bottom line. Ask:
- What are my liability limits?
- Do I have replacement cost or actual cash value?
- What's my deductible — and could I actually pay it tomorrow?
- What's NOT covered?
If you can't answer those questions, you don't know what you're buying.
We quote you with several companies and go over the differences — in plain English, not insurance jargon. Sometimes the cheapest option really is the one you'll pick. But you should know what you're getting before you sign.
Want us to take a look at what you've got? Give us a call at our Elkins or Buckhannon office. We can go over what's on your policy and quote it with several companies.
This is general information, not specific advice for your situation. Every policy is different.
This article is general information about how insurance commonly works. It is not a statement about your policy or a promise of coverage. Policies differ by company and state, and only your policy and your insurance company decide what is covered. Terms

Questions about this?
I'd be glad to explain further. Reach out to our Elkins or Buckhannon office.
Contact Ryan