Deer Season Is Claim Season
West Virginia has one of the highest deer-vehicle collision rates in the country. Here's what your insurance actually does — and doesn't — cover when Bambi wins.
Ryan Parrack
If you've driven in West Virginia for any length of time, you've had a close call with a deer. Maybe more than one. Maybe you weren't so lucky.
West Virginia regularly ranks at or near the top of the states for deer-vehicle collisions. It's not a matter of if — it's when. And most people don't think about what their insurance covers until they're standing on the shoulder of Route 19 staring at a caved-in hood.
What Covers a Deer Hit?
Here's the one that surprises people: it's not collision coverage. It's comprehensive.
Comprehensive generally covers things that happen to your car other than a collision — deer, falling trees, hail, theft, vandalism, a rock through the windshield. If you only carry liability, or if you dropped comprehensive to save money, a deer strike comes out of your pocket.
And deer damage isn't cheap. A deer hit can easily run $3,000-$6,000 in body work, and if the airbags deploy, you're looking at $8,000-$10,000 or more. On an older vehicle, that can be a total loss.
When It Happens the Most
October through December is peak season — deer are mating and moving. Dawn and dusk are the worst times. And if you're on a two-lane road through the woods — which is basically every road in West Virginia — your odds go up.
But it's not just fall. We see deer claims year-round. Spring is another spike when does are moving with fawns.
A Few Things That Actually Help
- Slow down at dawn and dusk, especially on rural roads
- If you see one deer, expect more — they travel in groups
- Don't swerve hard to avoid a deer — hitting a guardrail or rolling into a ditch is usually worse than the deer strike itself
- Use your high beams when there's no oncoming traffic
Check Your Coverage Now — Not After the Deer
Pull up your declarations page or call us. Do you have comprehensive? What's your deductible? If your vehicle would be hard to replace out of pocket, comprehensive is worth pricing.
Not sure what you've got? Give us a call at our Elkins or Buckhannon office. We can pull up your policy and go over it with you — takes about five minutes.
This is general information, not specific advice for your situation. Every policy is different.
This article is general information about how insurance commonly works. It is not a statement about your policy or a promise of coverage. Policies differ by company and state, and only your policy and your insurance company decide what is covered. Terms

Questions about claims help?
I'd be glad to explain further. Reach out to our Elkins or Buckhannon office.
Contact Ryan